It’s an Age of Adapt or Die – Chris Brummer [Season 3 | Episode #20]
It’s an Age of Adapt or Die – Chris Brummer [Season 3 | Episode #20]
Jens Seidl 00:00:19 All right. Welcome to another episode of The P.I.T. Exchange. My name is Jens Seidl. I’m your host for today, and I’ve got a great guest with us here today, Chris Brummer. Welcome, Chris.
Chris Brummer 00:00:30 Hopefully a great yes, but no, seriously, thank you so much. It’s a pleasure to be here.
Jens Seidl 00:00:35 Great. Thanks for for taking the time. as usual, I like to start with some this time. Not so random personal questions, because you did tell me in our prep call that you’re a Star Wars fan. so I’ll start with the first question here. Is it just Star Wars, or do you also like Star Trek? Because often that’s quite star.
Chris Brummer 00:00:59 Okay. So absolutely. I love Star Trek. in fact, I was, you know, going through the, the original 1960s sort of version of Star Trek just last week.
Chris Brummer 00:01:12 And I was thinking to myself, this is remarkably good. but, no, no, no, I, I like them both. Just don’t ask me to choose between the two, because, you know, I you know, I told you I didn’t want to get into controversial material, and you’d just be leading me, you know, directly into.
Jens Seidl 00:01:32 Well, I won’t ask you that hard.
Chris Brummer 00:01:36 But I we I’m. I’m a Trekkie. I’m definitely a Trekkie.
Jens Seidl 00:01:39 Okay, cool. Well, I would still lead you on some thinner ice there. Star Wars, which one is the favorite movie out of the Star Wars universe?
Chris Brummer 00:01:49 Favorite movie out of Star Wars universe? I mean, Empire Strikes Back has to, you know, continues to be just special. It continues to be just special. It’s still. It’s still the best one. It’s still the best one. All these years later. Yeah.
Jens Seidl 00:02:03 100%. Agreed. Great. And I’ll make it even more difficult. The favorite TV show of the Star Wars universe.
Jens Seidl 00:02:10 If you watched anybody do so.
Chris Brummer 00:02:12 Oh, yeah. Of course. I mean, I mean, yeah, literally I was I was watching Voyager. You know, which is, you know, you know, like, it just depends, you know, because Deep Space Nine is kind of interesting because you’re kind of staying in the same place.
Jens Seidl 00:02:25 okay. Stop. Oh, you’re talking Star Trek. No, I mean Star Trek.
Chris Brummer 00:02:28 I’m sorry. Star wars. Oh, see, you said the favorite episode. Or the favorite or the best series?
Jens Seidl 00:02:34 The best TV series. The best.
Chris Brummer 00:02:36 Okay, okay, okay. I’m sorry.
Jens Seidl 00:02:37 If.
Chris Brummer 00:02:37 You got any more than. I’m sorry. Mandalorian. Although I am not the biggest fan of of of Grogu, but I do like The Mandalorian. The whole sort of honor theme is really interesting. you know, I do like the armor. I like the idea of it. So I like bringing in the characters. You see the Luke Skywalker coming in years later.
Chris Brummer 00:03:02 That was pretty amazing. So, you know, you can just see what a real Jedi looks like in his prime. So yeah, it would, it would, it would it would be The Mandalorian.
Jens Seidl 00:03:10 Cool. Okay. Yeah. Mandalorian is right up there for me as well, but I like indoor even a little bit more.
Chris Brummer 00:03:15 Oh. Andor. yeah. Andor is like, well, you know, this is a very cognitive, intellectual show. So of course and or. No. And or was was terrific. Fantastic.
Jens Seidl 00:03:28 Absolutely cool. Well, we can’t spend the next half hour talking about Star Wars, unfortunately.
Chris Brummer 00:03:33 Well, we can’t today. It is it is actually possible. But we can obviously make the transition. Yeah.
Jens Seidl 00:03:41 All right. Well great. Thanks for playing along with that. And now if you just want to introduce yourself talk about a little bit what you do, what your current role is and what you’re working on.
Chris Brummer 00:03:51 Yeah. Well I am a professor of law over at Georgetown.
Chris Brummer 00:03:56 Actually, we’ll have some of my students over at the house later today for some pizza to talk about. Frankly, some of the issues we’ll be talking about on this podcast. I teach everything on, international financial regulation. of course, on, on on globalization and the law. I have a big, conference that we’re getting ready to host, here in Washington, DC called DC Fintech Week. over nine years running. So it’s become a little bit of an establishment here in, in Washington. And I have my own little startup, called called blueprint, which helps to operationalize on chain compliance, which in and of itself super interesting and is in many ways an application of, of years of, of, of research that I’ve been thinking about when it comes to the intersection of law and blockchains.
Jens Seidl 00:04:48 Okay, great. Well, we’re going to talk a lot about regulation today, but we’re also going to talk about blockchain tokenization. But let’s let’s start maybe on a high level with, regulation. I mean, there’s there’s so much happening in the payments world, so many new innovations coming in.
Jens Seidl 00:05:04 And I think you’re one of the proponents saying we need to adopt a different way how to regulate that. Do you want to tell us a little bit about what your thoughts are?
Chris Brummer 00:05:13 Yeah. You know, you know, one of the things.
Chris Brummer 00:05:15 And this is again, you know, getting to to sort of research over over years, you know, history is really useful even when it comes to law. And, and when you think about a field like securities regulation, which is sort of like the big course I teach. technology has played a very important role in securities regulation. There have been events and episodes in US securities regulation in particular, where the law has adapted to, technological changes. I mean, there are there are many instances. I mean, you could go back to the paperwork crisis in the United States, where in the 60s, people sort of, kept to, keeping paper records of documents and eventually. And people don’t even know this, but, you know, Wall Street actually had to, like, close on Wednesdays for people to reorganize.
Chris Brummer 00:06:15 You know, all the paper that was building up and, you know, the paper was literally getting scattered and disorganized and it was, you know, disrupting processes and the like. And there was like a paperwork crisis that the SEC had to respond to. And, you know, it coincided with this amazing invention called, you know, computers and, you know, digitalization. And, you know, there was like an episode in which even the original sort of 33 and 34 act had to be updated in certain kinds of ways, with ancillary rulemaking and other kinds of, sort of innovations that would accompany those rules and regulations. And you can just sort of see these episodes throughout history where, you know, the assumptions of 1933 and 34 and later 40 act and and like, you know, these assumptions that the major technology of finance was pieces of paper, you know, you know, as, as sort of that that backbone technology would, would evolve and grow, you would see all kinds of, responses, by regulatory agencies.
Chris Brummer 00:07:29 I mean, you can go all the way up to, you know, 2008 and the financial crisis where people saw, you know, credit default swaps and people as part of the Dodd-Frank act, pushed for the electronic ification and, you know, of of credit default swaps, you know, and saying, let’s, let’s push put some of these instruments on exchanges. You know, this was all ultimately, you know, thinking about, well, what are what’s what are the tools that are available to regulators. you know, there are pieces even within, again, the responses to the financial crisis where people were thinking about how do you house data? How do you share data? for different kinds of, frankly, even more complex financial instruments than what you would see in, you know, a typically sort of real world asset. And so I’ve always made this sort of observation that, you know, rules have always responded to technology. And, there’s no reason why one would say that this is any, any different, from the past, insofar as you have different kinds of technologies, different kinds of ways in which people are, transacting.
Chris Brummer 00:08:56 so the regulatory or administrative state has to do what it’s always done, which is to kind of think about how those transactions look and how they work, and then to adapt the sort of legacy regulatory infrastructure in a way that is fit for purpose and that reflects how transactions are actually done. And, you know, it’s it’s kind of interesting because I never really thought of it as a very controversial take. You know, I’m like, well, you know, like it’s it’s really I mean, it’s not new. and people have always kind of done it. so I’ve always been a little bit of a proponent of sort of kicking the tires and, you know, looking at the infrastructure and thinking through. Okay, well, do the rules reflect the infrastructure? are there assumptions about the back bone infrastructure that, for better or worse, may apply or don’t apply. And then when you think about, you know, sort of what the changes are to to then just, you know, update your, your rules.
Chris Brummer 00:10:08 And I think there’s a lot to work with. when you think about a distributed ledger or a blockchain, you know, that that creates lots of neat opportunities to rethink how things can work, and how things can be improved. and, you know, again, I never really thought of it as radical. You know, sometimes you sort of look at the news and like, you know, people sort of battling over all this. And I’m like, but, you know, the core idea is, oh, yeah, you have new technology for this stuff. I guess I should see if, like, the rule fits for how it runs. I just, you know, I’ve always been a little, surprise and, and even amused at, at, at how much energy is put into doing something that’s always been around.
Jens Seidl 00:10:53 Yeah. And look that that all makes sense. And I think that’s I mean, you make it more simple than it probably is, right. There’s some complexity to this, but from from One Nation’s point of view that is pretty straightforward.
Jens Seidl 00:11:05 But we’re talking about 200 countries or so around the world that are looking at similar problems. And that’s where it gets really well.
Chris Brummer 00:11:13 That is an entirely different. Okay. Well okay. I was I was I was okay. Well I was thinking a little bit more on in terms of like how do you make a rule or should one make rules, that reflect the technology of the times, which I don’t think should consume as much of the sort of, let’s call it the, the, the political energy as it does because it just, you know, it delays reforms that promote efficiency, investor protection, as well as, you know, you know, capital allocation and, and, and capital formation. So, you know, I just don’t think that’s a great debate. Now, the international part. you know, it’s interesting. Again, I teach an international financial regulatory course, and I’m introducing students to international financial regulation. And I kind of started off with, congratulations, you’re in law school and you’re in my class.
Chris Brummer 00:12:23 But for the entire semester, I’m going to teach you about things that are not law. And they just sort of, you know, they’re like, yeah, yeah, like like literally the entire semester, you know, you know, even when you think about things like the Basel Accord, like there is no treaty for the Basel Accord, there is no Basel Accord. Treaty. Right. Like there is no Treaty of Iosco. You know, the international, organization of securities commissions. Right. Like, literally the instruments of getting stuff done across borders. You know, you have, like, rules and methodologies and then, like, you’ll have this line, even from the FSB or something that I’ll say, by the way, this is not like legal. It’s not a formal legal obligation, but but, you know, great. You guys get to learn about all this stuff when you’re in law school. Non law. Law. Right. And it reflects you know a little bit what you’re talking about that is inherent to markets and coordinating markets.
Chris Brummer 00:13:22 regardless as to whether or not it’s about fintech or anything. again, this stuff isn’t that new, but you can go all the way back to, the frankly sort of de facto standard setting in the monetary world. you know, when you have like, the silver standard and the gold standard and like, you know, frankly, where you did have an attempt for like literally treaty based monetary law in Europe to, you know, our modern international financial regulation, which, interestingly enough, you know, for people who are really nerding out, coincides, you know, with, you know, departures from the gold standard, like, I mean, when you, when you, when you really start to think about what happens in the 1970s, right, where people go off the gold standard, once you go off the gold standard, FX markets become, you know, more, more important, you know, liberalization of of of, of, of capital accounts becomes much more important, you know, when all that happens.
Chris Brummer 00:14:32 And so now money starts to sort of slosh more freely across borders. That’s also coinciding with, you know, computerization and digitalization of, of, of the global economy. And then you know that, you know. And like like people don’t always like, always kind of put everything together, right. Like, okay, now we’re getting okay. You know, it’s like, okay, we’re going off this gold standard you’re getting you know, we’re thinking a little bit more about time zones. You know, we’re thinking a little bit more about what happens with more capital mobility. And then, you know, you get the Basel Concordat, right. You know, and people are like, okay, guys, you know, we’re going to have a plan to have a plan, you know, you know, with with the central bankers. And now we’re going to start to pull on some of these, you know, institutions like, you know, the G10 and others in new, new kinds of ways.
Chris Brummer 00:15:35 you know, around that same time, you know, I ask those, you know, starting to get revved up, right? You know, and you have all of this stuff that’s kind of happening at the same time. you know, as not just technology changes, but also just, just, you know, money changes and, and, and, different kinds of decisions when it comes to the supervision of the macro economy. Right. And, and you and people very quickly start to see, that doing that kind of stuff is different from determining tariff schedules. You know, with the gap. Right. So, you know, it’s not it’s not a hey, I know what we need to do. Let’s, let’s have a new international treaty for financial regulation. Like that was that was clearly not the choice that was made at that point in time. And it’s all reflecting what what your comment is sort of hitting at, which is just making decisions and coordinating between Countries on any matter of financial regulation isn’t easy.
Chris Brummer 00:16:48 And, you know, financial innovation and particularly financial technology doesn’t make it any easier. It’s true. It doesn’t make it any easier because like, people don’t even have don’t even know what they’re doing in their own jurisdictions. So it’s a little bit like, how are they going to figure out how to how to make rules across borders. Yeah.
Jens Seidl 00:17:11 Well, and let’s stick with what’s I mean fundamentally 50 year old technology now. Right. You said computers came up around that time, and we still really haven’t cracked that hard nut of how to make cross-border payments completely fast. No friction and low cost. Right. And most of the friction comes not from the technology side. It comes from very different legislation and regulation. So what are we going to do about this?
Chris Brummer 00:17:40 Yeah. I don’t know. I mean, you know. You know. I mean, look, I think it’s absolutely true that that the frictions are now and arguably have for a while been more regulatory, as opposed to sort of technological.
Chris Brummer 00:18:02 And now technologies do reflect their local regulations. So, you know, as the technology matures, you know, it kind of cements the underlying regulatory apparatus, on top of which it’s, it’s built. But, but, but, but you know, payments, you know, again, I’m a, you know, securities lawyer bye bye bye training. You know and I, I recall when the European prospectus directive came out, you know this starting to date me a little bit. and there were like attempts, even when it comes to the offering of a security, like, like, how do you standardize something that in a way is a little bit easier than payments, arguably. Right. Which is like disclosures like, well, what information like shouldn’t you know. Can we really make the argument that what is material is so dramatically different in terms of what an investor needs to know from one country, or even better, from, you know, if you’re in Europe or the United States. But even when that came out and people were looking at the US model, you know, there are differences and different markets had their different preferences and they had sort of their, their, advantages.
Chris Brummer 00:19:23 And, you know, one of the things that I tell my students is whenever you look at a rule or law across borders, not to be too much of an academic here, but it’s like game theory is super helpful, right? Because you can you can you can kind of see like, you know, I and I tell my students, like, you know, there are all kinds of game theory models with this stuff. Like, is this a, you know, some kind of assurance game where, like, one regulator says, look, I’m gonna go out there, but you know, you know, like, I need to know that someone’s going to be out there with me because I can’t do it by myself, you know? Is this like a Weakest Link game where, you know, you have, like this, you know, the island or whatever, and you need to, like, build, build, build something against rising, you know, sea levels or something. And just that one guy, you know, messes it up and doesn’t do the work.
Chris Brummer 00:20:11 And now the entire, you know, island floods, you know, so is this like a truly systemic risk? Kind of a question. Right. And and knowing what, you know, you know, like, you know, I go to them, you know, I take them to stack hunts I think, you know, battle the sexes games, you know, weakest link games and stuff like that and like sort of thinking through like, well, you know, which which game are we talking about here? and are the games different depending on payments, you know, or crypto or RWA or quantum computing or, you know, AI. You know, like. Like, are there different? You know, like like, do we know what we’re working with in terms of the incentive structure? Is is helpful because at that point in time, when you when you kind of know what game you’re in, then you can build the, regulatory approach and, and frankly, the, the diplomatic approach.
Jens Seidl 00:21:08 Okay. And but do you think we have the right mechanisms or industry bodies in place to actually make that happen? Because wherever we see progress in cross-border, it’s mostly because two countries get together. They work out, a treaty between themselves. They figure out how to normalize the legislation between themselves and get that one quarter to go. But again, if we’re looking at a global network so much more complex.
Chris Brummer 00:21:33 Well, it’s really complex because you have, again, you know, fintech is and I’m going to use fintech, but payments obviously, you know, is a great example of it because, you know, on the one hand, you know, you’ll you’ll have fed now which was a little bit like a fed later. You know, it was kind of like the you know, kind of joke. You know, it kind of rolls out. but by then you have, you know, stablecoins that are, you know, you know, sort of capturing market share. You know, the question of tokenized deposits, you have the on and off question of CBDCs, you know.
Chris Brummer 00:22:11 and, and there’s a lot to have to handle because each one of them presents different kinds of policy questions. And I sometimes I don’t know if the question is, is there the right infrastructure or is there enough infrastructure? Is there enough of it? Right. Because the use cases and applications and the technologies are multiplying and the questions that you have to tackle are multiplying. And again just think about those four product areas I just identified. And that’s not even talking again about like, you know, generative AI and like what that means for payments, right? You know, it’s not even getting into well, the knock on impact of like what that means for atomic settlement and the knock on impact of like, okay, like what does that mean for systemic risk or managing risk and and and you know, other critical issues that will, you know, have to figure out, so, you know, I, I, I think that the fact that things like the Financial Stability Board. Remain important, you know, whatever the geopolitical changes in the world are and, you know, there are many of them, you know, around the world, There’s still sort of this understanding that you have to have flexibility and an increasing premium on speed when it comes to at least and frankly, an acceptance of risk, not the risk in terms of the instrument itself, but an acceptance that the policy position that you’re putting forward may not be perfect, but you can’t make perfect the enemy of the good, because if you’re trying to get to the perfect outcome, it’ll take you whatever, 2 or 3 years, which is in technological terms, you know, you push something out and the technology has evolved so far beyond what your original prescription is that that the international standard ends up being relatively useless.
Chris Brummer 00:24:19 So I think that there’s like an understanding increasingly, although I do think that what central bankers it is hard. It is in particular central bankers. I love my central bankers. I talk to central bankers probably almost every day in one way or another. But but, you know, like like, you know, they like academics sort of live in, in a more, sort of, intentionally so, like cloistered environment. But they are clearly understanding that, you know, if they don’t do something and if they don’t act and, you know, understanding what the technology looks like and act with a certain kind of speed, you know, there’s a risk to their ability to being able to fulfill their own mandate. As I tell my colleagues in the academy, I tell my colleagues in industry, I tell my colleagues on the regulatory side, you know, it is it’s an age of, you know, adapt or die. And the central banking community is not immune to that reality.
Jens Seidl 00:25:26 Okay. well, let’s let’s stick with tokenization then.
Jens Seidl 00:25:30 because if when I look at tokenization now, that’s really fragmentation galore, right? You already mentioned a few of the different flavors of tokenization, from tokenized deposits to CBDCs to stablecoins. and none of these RWA.
Chris Brummer 00:25:47 Other other kinds of.
Chris Brummer 00:25:48 RWA, tokenized gold. I mean, you know, whatever.
Jens Seidl 00:25:51 Yeah, they’re not necessarily talking to each other, right? They don’t. Sitting on the same ledger. They’re not sitting on the same platform necessarily. You need exchanges in between. so is are we going the right way here, or should we also look at how can we normalize and standardize some of this stuff.
Chris Brummer 00:26:09 So I 2 to 2 really big questions. You know, I look I mean, to a certain degree, every market is fragmented, right? Like, you know, we don’t have like a unified, stock exchange or securities market. And, you know, again, making analogies here in the capital market space. You have dark pools. You have exchanges. You know, you have, you know, broker dealers, ATS and by the way, for tokenized markets, all of those entities are relevant.
Chris Brummer 00:26:45 Like you have different jurisdictions who are trying to figure out when you bring the tokenized, you know, this is where the payments and the and the, you know, it’s kind of interesting, right? Because you have like the with stablecoins or whatever, like what’s the settlement asset going to be for the on chain security. So, you know, these worlds are kind of smashing together in a way. But you know, you do have fragmentation just already in, capital markets. So there is a reasonable question as to why would you think it would be any, any, any different in tokenized markets? Because sometimes they’re targeting the legacy infrastructure. Right. So you’re saying, okay, you have a tokenized exchange or you have an exchange and a stock exchange, let me go and create my crypto exchange. Or, you know, the the on chain version of it or something like that. And then the legacy exchange says, oh, well, you can do that. I can do it too. And then they sort of try to deploy their, their, their version of it.
Chris Brummer 00:27:46 and you can go across almost any product space. the interesting question which I, which you’re raising is, well, well, what happens with those products that don’t have a legacy sort of place to necessarily be traded? you know, if you’re talking about tokenized deposit, which I never really thought about in quite this way, because I think about tokenized deposits as operating inherently within sort of a banking payments rail kind of an ecosystem. But, you know, if you ever wanted, say, a tokenized deposit to be a settlement instrument for a securities transaction. You know, there’s that kind of interesting question, you know. Well, how is that supposed to work? Which, you know, especially, you know, again, you know, when you have fragmentation of the market, I think that tokenized deposits also raise really interesting legal questions that I’m not, certain the responses have been, to your point, standardized. Right. And sometimes it’s not necessarily is this good or bad? It’s just, it’s almost a, as a it’s a game theory question, right? Like it’s a okay.
Chris Brummer 00:29:20 is this a nobody has street lights in the world, so we just have to agree on what color the street lights are and everyone’s agnostic to it. Or is this a world where, you know, in theory, it’d be great if we were all driving on the same side of the street. But you’ve chosen the left hand side. I’ve chosen the right hand side. And nobody wants to incur the switching costs. Right? Or, you know, like like, you know, like like what kind of thing? Which I’m not entirely certain about, but like, like, here’s certain kinds of legal questions where I’m like, I don’t know if there’s like a distributive like or inherent conflict, but there are trade offs and whether and whether or not everybody agrees on which trade offs to take. It’s not clear to me. Right. So, you know, if you have a tokenized deposit, like if you’re, you know, that obligation is is to whom and what precisely is a little bit of a question.
Chris Brummer 00:30:15 Right. And if you can have the third party how to hold a tokenized deposit and then, you know, and it floats around, then that person, you know, the holder, you know, are we talking about a bearer instrument. If it really is a bearer instrument, you know, like how is that supposed to work with the underlying account? You know, and you can have answers to these questions. But as I, you know, randomly kind of talk to two folks, I hear very different answers to the legal question. Right? And I don’t think yet the answers to those questions are necessarily coming from a what’s competitive from my market structure, because I don’t think people have thought it out that that much, frankly. Right. So it’s not quite like, look, I have my capital market. I want to protect myself from your capital market. So we’re all going to go to war over this? I don’t get that. That’s like what’s going on. But I do get a sense that people aren’t landing quite literally on the same page on like very, very simple, very simple legal questions.
Chris Brummer 00:31:20 Right? I mean, like, like this is not complex, right? and and that will lead to fragmentation just in and of itself. so and so again some of the stuff it’s a you know, sure. You know their politics and finance and money involved. But I’ve been surprised by how often it’s just like, you know, people aren’t landing on the same legal question or very, very baseline fundamental answers to two basic legal questions. And I’m, you know, that’s that’s going to create lots of difficulties later on.
Jens Seidl 00:32:01 Yeah. And I guess what makes it worse is that these are experts talking to each other. Oh, yeah. They can’t even agree for for the layman, for the users of these services. It’s super confusing. I mean, it was confusing when stablecoins weren’t stable at all. Right. Where you had the Terra Luna kind of stuff happening. and now it’s already beginning to get confusing because I think people thought, okay, if it’s a tokenized deposit, That’s a bank. You’ve got your insurance around that as well.
Jens Seidl 00:32:30 So whatever money I do exactly there is going to be insured. But now they’re moving also into the stablecoin space. And the banks are issuing stablecoins where you don’t have.
Chris Brummer 00:32:39 The regular.
Jens Seidl 00:32:39 Assurance.
Chris Brummer 00:32:40 Exactly. And then confusing. It’s like, by the way, there’s not insurance. And you’re like, okay, well what does that mean? Right. And then again and then to your point and then they’re like saying, okay, well okay. Tokenize deposits. That sounds great. And then you’re like, but are those, you know, like are these are these bearer instruments, you know, and, and and and so there’s a certain level of, again, you know, kinds of trade offs, if one will, in terms of the product, and utility, you know, cross-border application like, you know, is oh, so tokenize deposit. So I can just like, you know, use this and send it to, like, Norway or Kenya. Oh, well, maybe not, you know, and and and and even differences of you know, one of the things that that that I’ve found, you know, kind of interesting, you know, like you get all this transparency, obviously, when you’re working and operating on a, on a blockchain, but you also have opportunities for mischief.
Chris Brummer 00:33:44 And you’re talking about like, do you know, things, you know, you’re mentioning with the, you know, the stablecoin issue and, you know, the tokenized deposits, but you also have these issues of counterfeit tokens, right? You know, and, and, and, you know, our, our is a stablecoin, really a stablecoin, especially when you release it out of its private, sort of internal loop. you know, you have that issue and, you know, with, with with my startup, it was it was very, very interesting because one of the first things we did besides thinking about Meka and like, how do you kind of TurboTax the a white paper because I’m an American. So like we think about things very, very sort of like there’s this thing that everybody in the United States knows, which is the service for your taxes. And like, how do you fill your taxes? And there’s this little software program. This is for generative, you know, AI where everybody would use it to kind of produce their tax filing since, like, okay, can you do that with, with MCA? And then we realized that, oh, wow.
Chris Brummer 00:34:49 You know, with stablecoins and obviously tokenized deposits. But again, they’re usually more closed loop. You know, what happens with stablecoins or meme coins or anyone else when you go to an hosted wallet and you see ten versions of it, like to your point, how how.
Chris Brummer 00:35:04 Are you supposed to know like, you know, like like not just what is the difference between a stablecoin.
Chris Brummer 00:35:09 And the and the tokenized deposit, but like, which one is real or not real? And and with the startup, it’s like, you know, it’s called blueprint. Get it? Like you get a, a blueprint of an asset and everything. But we were like, oh, man. You know, like, that kind of sucks. So how? You know, we work with some central banks. Bank of Lithuania. And we were kind of, you know, kind of trying to think through. Well, well, how can you think through this, counterfeit issue to distinguish what’s real or not? And that after you do that, it raises a number of other questions like, there are a lot of things that you know, but don’t necessarily know.
Chris Brummer 00:35:51 both because of the legal framework in which the, the token or the stablecoin operates, but also, because stablecoins, even today can be very different. You know, and you were mentioning the fragmentation, you know, the fragmentation that happens when that asset is operating across multiple chains, which, by the way, tokenized deposits would have that same question if they were ever to exit like a, you know, a closed loop, you know, like and the different sort of bridging infrastructure and how all that’s supposed to kind of kind of operate, you know, introduces other important questions as to, you know, what consumer protection should mean, right. now, again, you know, I choose to I don’t choose to I think it’s necessary to look at these questions from the standpoint of, okay. Here’s the challenge that may be created. And by the way, counterfeiting is last I heard, not exactly new to payments. You know, that this is I mean yeah, but whatever. Like okay. So you know, here’s, here’s a, you know, a new version of the problem.
Chris Brummer 00:37:13 are there new versions of the solution? Yeah. And that’s when you get into, embedded. compliance, embedded supervision, you know, at the protocol level in what regulators can do. I think the standardization question is also the sort of remains and, you know, one of the big projects over the Fintech Foundation, which is sort of like the, the big nonprofit that I have that, that, that hosts the the conference is to sort of think about that, question because it’s it’s like, to, you know, technologically you have different types of problems and solutions, but they all remain legal in nature. Then you need to again, think about what that standard setting process kind of looks like.
Jens Seidl 00:38:07 And maybe on that, I think it’s now a couple of years ago, so that the BIS and Augustin Carstens, who ran the BIS at the time, published this paper around the the internet. Right. Yes. And that seems to have gone quiet. Why is that, in your opinion, was was he on to something with that paper or was it not the right answer?
Chris Brummer 00:38:27 I think the internet I think, you know, the Unified ledger, sort of concept.
Chris Brummer 00:38:34 I think sometimes it’s good to, to sort of think about certain things as, as, as maybe where the direction of travel people would like or maybe even to frame it as a okay, if we were still working on older models as to what we think financial stability, transmission of monetary policy, etc. should look like, here is what the natural evolution would look like. probably would have been a sort of a framing that could help. And I think it still was, although obviously, you know, there was a there was a position that was taken, you know, to sort of kick off a conversation, my approach, And you know well you know so so we have this, this index that we’ll be releasing. Over at the conference. And we, you know, I believe and I’ve testified on this before over at Congress and I think over the European Parliament. Right. The way that we think about standard setting has to continue to evolve, these problems in order to move quickly. I mean, that you probably have to have a much more heterogeneous set of people together when you start to write the standard immediately.
Chris Brummer 00:39:51 So, you know, what we did as a kind of experiment and, you know, we’ll be releasing this and it’s kind of kind of neat, is we notice that we don’t have like fintech specific sort of master standards. So, you know, we have like a, a regulatory futures index project where we have central bankers shout out to my central banker friends. we have industry people, you know, you know, we have former regulators, we have academics, we have compliance people, in five different working groups that are very thematically different. and, you know, they they cover everything from rules, clarity and comprehensiveness, which is a standard in and of itself all the way to the more traditional things like resilience and consumer protection. And then we combine things that people don’t always put together, like, how would you think about financial inclusion, but also access to capital from a fundraising perspective if you’re a firm. And to put that into one category, because they really are in some instances, they get to questions about, you know, how one participates in a in a financial economy and, and, and to sort of think about, like what kind of general standards you can have.
Chris Brummer 00:41:10 And we have all these people in the same room. And so first of all, I think, I mean, I’m, I’m, I, you know, I’ve been around for a while. I don’t know if I’ve ever seen, like the regulators and academics and industry actually like, shutting off ideas to each other, international organizations, you know, kind of thinking to themselves, well, what would the benchmark look like? And then we’re we’re going to release it, in a very humble way as to not say, here’s what the standards are, but when we when we send out, it’ll it’ll be pretty impressive. it’s a literally a we’re creating an application, that, that invites people to criticize us, like literally literally like, what did we get wrong? Right. And then even going to Roadshow to make it very, very digital, we’re gamified different elements of it. you know, like literally we have game like engineers like to help us do this and, you know, to to really think about what these standards can and should look like, you know, in order to create speed, to get crowdsourced information and then to go out and think about, well, what does it mean to apply these standards and best practices globally? And, you know, it’s it’s, it’s an invitation to not just think about the substance and the new kinds of categories that you have to have, you know, for fintech, but also process.
Chris Brummer 00:42:36 Right? Like, you know, like, is there a way in a digital world where you have 24 over seven, you know, information? Is there a way to to rethink notice and comment? Right. Like is it like I mean you know you know is there is there a way to rethink, you know what the user, the UI you know, or the UX like the, the, the, the user experience should be for people who are engaging with central bankers and regulators. Right. Like in a way where you can get broader swaths of input and data in real time for regulators that they can draw on. And, frankly, for consumers, for investors, for entrepreneurs write that they can draw on. to really again, use the moment to, to to rethink not just the, the, the substance but but the process. And again, there’s a history of rethinking the process in international financial regulation. You know, there are moments in time where, you know, people thought, well, you know, maybe let’s rethink what the BIS is.
Chris Brummer 00:43:52 Maybe it’s not just for World war, you know, you know, reparations. But maybe we should start to think about it, not just for even monetary policy, but for regulatory policy. There was a moment, right. And, you know, you get to 2009, 2010 where you think to yourself, well, this financial stability Forum should maybe be rethought as a financial stability board and maybe think a little bit more broadly about, you know, what its remit should be. Or the G20, which was a talking shot. Like maybe we should rethink it a little bit. Right. So I think there are moments. I mean, it’s not new to international financial regulation where you rethink not just the substance but also the process. And when you look at the explosion, not just of information technology, but the the platforms on which trading and financial activity and everything takes place. Well, let’s go and try that. You know, and that’s a little bit of, you know what? What I’ve been very sort of thankful, you know, just to sort of see everybody kind of volunteering a little bit and pitching in just just to see, you know, to, to to begin to imagine how that looks.
Chris Brummer 00:44:58 I do think that regulators and central bankers and authorities around the world, international standard setting bodies, you know, and you see it over time. If you look at their websites, you know, you sort of see an attempt to kind of, you know, adapt to remain relevant. but, you know, that pressure is going to really grow quickly. and, and, you know, they’ve largely been able to rise to the occasion, but this will be, you know, another, another instance when, when they’re going to have to do so. So, there’s going to be and, and if they don’t, it’s going to be, it’ll make it much more difficult for them to fulfill their own mandates. yeah.
Jens Seidl 00:45:43 Yeah. Okay. Well, Chris, we’re almost out of time. and before we wrap up, maybe just again taking it up to a very high level and trying to look ten, 20 even more years into the future. But what do you think that this whole ecosystem is going to look like? Is all of the asset, side? Is that all going to be tokenized? How about the settlement side? Is it also all tokenized or is is it just another addition to what we have?
Chris Brummer 00:46:11 Well, given the fact that apparently in four years, four years, generative AI will destroy humanity.
Chris Brummer 00:46:17 you know. Yeah, right. I think maybe this is all just moot in the first place. but but but assuming, you know, we have not become the planet Krypton. you know, and and and and and where we may be standing. You know, I, I am not smart enough to figure out how we end up in a world where. Tokenization is not the primary sort of rail for most, for lack of a better word. Financial transactions. You know, like, as a, as a, as a, you know, from a back office and even compliance standpoint. Like, like like I’m, I’m actually not smart enough to think of like, why it Now what? Why? Why we wouldn’t have that world now. Now, mind you when I say that, I’m not trying to say. Oh, yes, there’s this. You know, it’s an unmitigated good without any trade offs whatsoever. Like, you know, I’m not, I’m not, I’m not. I’m not saying that at all.
Chris Brummer 00:47:28 I’m just trying to say that, you know, it seems to me to be a pretty straightforward case that you make that, there are certain benefits, that you get, when you are able to tokenize transactions on a blockchain. and obviously with AI assuming, again, our computer overlords do not, you know, make us into the matrix and plug us, you know, our life force into them. You know, I think it’s it’s pretty obvious that the, you know, AI applications on those rails are also going to increase the use cases dramatically. And so why would people again, you know, not want to move, those transactions to that space? So it’s kind of like a cloud, you know, kind of analogy. I mean, I can, I guess, not move to the cloud. But, you know, I don’t know, that probably is not great for me, you know. so, I’m not a, you know, again, a prediction, a big prediction guy, but but I do make, it’s hard for me to see why, whatever the trade offs are, why you wouldn’t work it out.
Chris Brummer 00:48:54 Because it seems pretty obvious to to me that the benefits outweigh the, the the trade offs, which is also, I think, one reason why, you know, central bankers, regulators and everything. Like they really have a very challenging but necessary task ahead of them because I. I doubt that I’m, an oddball in this way. and I think that they’re going to, you know, they’re going to have to come up with relevant solutions. Now, part of the relevance is going to be being, frankly, being serious about what those tradeoffs are. Right. Like, and also being serious about what, you know, making sure that the go to market for the solutions is accelerated. So, yeah, there are some, some problems. So which means that you better figure out and think through what are the crypto native or blockchain native supervisory approaches. You want to take, compliance approaches you want to take, and to make that as much of your mandate and your critical thinking and reasoning skills as you know, how do you enable more efficiency, you know, in the market.
Chris Brummer 00:50:11 and getting that that that mix right. But again, overall, you know, as a, you know, as a venture capitalist saying, you know, the thesis of tokenization, I mean, it’s it’s a very strong thesis. And, I think it’s something the world needs to, get ready for if they haven’t already.
Jens Seidl 00:50:27 All right. Great. Thank you. Chris. Unfortunately, we’re out of time. But before we wrap, let our listeners know about the D.C. Fintech Week. When is it happening?
Chris Brummer 00:50:35 October 13th through 16. It’s going to be a really great event. We are so, so delighted. I mean, we have the CEOs of the New York Stock Exchange, you know, Terry Duffy from CME. We have the CEO of Kalki. We have there are so many CEOs. CEO of you know, remotely you know Zales CEO as well as central bankers from, Brazil. We we have the, the former Fatf, head of Fatf. We have regulators, the FDIC. And what’s really neat about it is a little bit like like the index, a bunch of nerds coming to DC.
Chris Brummer 00:51:18 It is absolutely free. We do it as a public service every year. it’ll be at one day at the world Bank. Another day over at AWS headquarters. So we’ll have some demos from AI to Perpetual Futures. Oh, we have coming in from Singapore. You know, the CEO of Hyper Liquid. I mean, it’s it’s it’s a neat event. it’s it’s for people who want to learn, about things in a serious, but, but frankly, kind of fun way. I mean, we, we certainly make, make fun of ourselves, but there are a lot of people stacked, I think, together who are pretty impressive. So nobody wants to embarrass themselves that much. and, you know, it’s it’s, you know, over nine years running and it’s become a real, I think, a tradition in the city. So, we’d love to see everyone in town the week of October 13th in Washington, D.C..
Jens Seidl 00:52:17 Good stuff. Chris. Thank you so much for coming on to the podcast.
Jens Seidl 00:52:21 I’m.
Chris Brummer 00:52:22 Thanks so much for the invitation.
Jens Seidl 00:52:23 Live long and prosper, or may the force.
Jens Seidl 00:52:25 Be with you. Thank you sir. Yeah. For sure. Okay.
Jens Seidl 00:52:30 Great to have you. Thank you so much, Chris.
Chris Brummer 00:52:31 All right. Bye bye.
Jens Seidl 00:52:33 All right. That concludes another episode of the P.I.T. Exchange. Please do like follow. Do whatever you need to do on your platform to make sure you don’t miss any of our future episodes. Thank you, and see you soon.
Finance is moving onto new rails, but regulation is still trying to keep up.
In this episode, our hosts sits down with Chris Brummer, CEO of Fintech Foundation, to look at what happens when financial technology moves faster than the rules designed to govern it. It’s not a completely new problem. Financial regulation has adapted to major changes before, from the paper crisis that once forced Wall Street to close on Wednesdays to the shift towards electronic trading. But today’s challenge is different. Blockchains, tokenized assets and AI don’t stop at national borders, while regulation largely does.
That creates some big questions. What exactly does a token represent? What protections should apply? And how can assets move between different platforms when there isn’t yet a common set of rules? Chris argues that regulators need to think differently about these technologies and, importantly, work together before standards become too difficult to change. The opportunity is significant: faster, more flexible and more programmable finance. But getting there will require regulators and the industry to adapt alongside the technology. As Chris puts it, “It’s an age of adapt or die.” Listen to the full episode now!
As financial technology moves ahead, the conversation around regulation, tokenisation and the future of payments is becoming increasingly important. These are some of the questions we’ll be exploring at the Central Bank Payments Conference 2027, in Bangkok, Thailand, bringing together central banks, regulators and payments leaders to discuss what comes next.
Upcoming P.I.T. Exchange Podcast Guests:
- Zennon Kapron, Director, GL Insight
- Allison Middleton, Deputy Manager, Digital Currency Adoption, Central Bank of The Bahamas
- Kosta Peric, Deputy Director, Inclusive Financial Systems, Gates Foundation
- Victoria Cleland, Chief Cashier and Special Advisor to the Governors, Bank of England
- Sharmyn Powell, Director, Payment System Modernization and Financial Inclusion, Eastern Caribbean Central Bank
LISTEN ON THIS WEBSITE AND ON
Disclaimer: While we embrace open dialogue and value diverse perspectives, it’s important to note that the views expressed by individuals in our podcast episodes are entirely their own. They may not necessarily align with the views, opinions, or positions of the organization they are associated with.















